US20060182879A1

US20060182879A1 - Microelectronic workpiece for electrochemical deposition processing and methods of manufacturing and using such microelectronic workpieces

Info

Publication number: US20060182879A1
Application number: US11/348,202
Authority: US
Inventors: Dale Collins
Original assignee: Individual
Current assignee: Individual
Priority date: 2002-08-21
Filing date: 2006-02-06
Publication date: 2006-08-17
Also published as: US7025866B2; US20040038052A1

Abstract

Methods for forming microelectronic workpieces used in electrochemical deposition processes, methods of depositing a conductive layer on a microelectronic workpiece, and articles for electrochemical deposition in semiconductor fabrication. One aspect of the invention is directed toward methods for forming microelectronic workpieces that are well-suited for electrochemical deposition processes. On embodiment of such a method comprises depositing a first conductive material on a workpiece to form an electrically conductive first layer that conforms to the workpiece. This embodiment further includes forming a seed region defined by a second layer of a second conductive material on the first layer, and forming a contact region defined by an exposed portion of the first layer that is not covered by the second layer. The contact region can extend around at least a portion of the perimeter of the workpiece.

Description

CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION

This application is a divisional of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/225,585, filed Aug. 21, 2001, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.

TECHNICAL FIELD

The present invention relates to microelectronic workpieces with barrier layers and seed layers that are configured for electrochemical deposition processing, and methods of making and using such microelectronic workpieces.

BACKGROUND

Microelectronic devices, such as semiconductor devices, field emission displays, read/write heads, and other products that include integrated circuits, are generally fabricated on and/or in microelectronic workpieces using several different types of machines (“tools”). Many such processing machines have a single processing station that performs one or more procedures on the workpieces. In a typical fabrication process, for example, one or more layers of conductive materials are formed on the workpieces during deposition stages. The workpieces are then typically etched and/or planarized (i.e., chemical-mechanical planarization) to remove an “overburden” portion of the deposited conductive layers and thus form electrically isolated contacts and/or interconnect lines.
Plating tools that plate metals or other materials onto the workpieces are becoming an increasingly useful type of processing tool. Electroplating and electroless plating techniques can be used to deposit copper, solder, permalloy, gold, silver, platinum, polymeric materials and other materials onto workpieces for forming blanket layers or patterned layers. A typical copper plating process involves depositing a barrier layer on the workpiece that conforms to micro-recesses and other features and then depositing a copper seed layer onto the barrier layer using chemical vapor deposition (CVD), physical vapor deposition (PVD), electroless plating, or other suitable deposition processes. After forming the seed layer, a blanket layer or patterned layer of copper is plated onto the workpiece by applying an appropriate electrical potential between the seed layer and another electrode in the presence of an electroprocessing solution (i.e., an acidic electrolyte). The workpiece is then cleaned, etched, and/or annealed in subsequent procedures before transferring the workpiece to other processing machines.
FIG. 1 schematically illustrates an embodiment of a single-wafer processing station 1 that includes a container 2 for receiving a flow of electroplating solution from a fluid inlet 3 at a lower portion of the container 2. The processing station 1 can include an anode 4, a plate-type diffuser 6 having a plurality of apertures 7, and a workpiece holder 9 for carrying a workpiece 5. The workpiece holder 9 can include a plurality of electrical contacts arranged to circumscribe a first diameter. The contacts of the workpiece holder 9 contact a perimeter portion of the workpiece for providing electrical current to the seed layer on the surface of the workpiece 5. When the seed layer is biased with a negative potential relative to the anode 4, it acts as a cathode. In operation, the electroplating fluid flows around the anode 4, through the apertures 7 in the diffuser 6, and against the plating surface of the workpiece 5. The electroplating solution is typically an acidic electrolyte that conducts electrical current between the anode 4 and the cathodic seed layer on the surface of the workpiece 5. Therefore, ions in the electroplating solution plate the surface of the workpiece 5.
The plating machines used in fabricating microelectronic devices must meet many specific performance criteria. For example, many processes must be able to form small contacts in submicron recesses, such as vias that are less than 0.5 micron wide and are desirably on the order of 0.1 micron wide. The plated metal layers should also be of a uniform thickness across the surface of the workpiece 5. One factor that influences the uniformity of the plated layer, and especially the integrity of the plated material in the submicron micro-recesses, is the current density across the surface of the workpiece.
Another objective of electrochemical deposition processes according to the prior art is to maximize the real estate available for forming integrated circuits on the workpiece. Existing contact assemblies typically include a plurality of fingers that project radially inwardly from a ring. Each of the fingers includes a contact point, and the contact points are typically arranged to circumscribe a circle with a slightly small diameter than the workpiece. To maximize the available real estate for forming integrated circuits, the diameter circumscribed by the contact points is typically selected to be as close to the perimeter edge of the workpiece as possible. Therefore, a significant number of tool manufacturers have expended significant resources to develop contact rings that minimize the distance that the contacts extend radially inwardly from the perimeter edge of the workpiece.
Although electrochemical deposition processes are widely used in semiconductor fabrication applications, it is becoming difficult to form uniform layers that completely fill the submicron micro-recesses. One factor contributing to the difficulty of electrochemical deposition processes is that very thin seed layers are necessary to fill 0.1-0.5 micron recesses. The ultrathin seed layers are typically discontinuous layers of copper that do not uniformly cover the topography of the workpieces. As a result, an IR drop occurs across thin seed layers, and the amount of copper that each contact engages varies across the workpiece. The IR drop is exacerbated because oxidation greatly impairs the conductivity of the copper seed layer. Moreover, acidic electroplating baths momentarily etch the copper seed layer before an electrical current is established in the bath causing a further reduction of conductivity. Thus, reduced conductivity of the copper seed layer further increases the IR drop.
The IR drop across the seed layer and the non-uniformities of ultrathin seed layers having a thickness of between 100-1000 Å cause a non-uniform current distribution in which the electrical current at the center of the workpiece is less than the current at the perimeter for an initial portion of the plating cycle. This produces non-uniform surfaces across the workpiece and voids within the submicron micro-recesses. Therefore, the semiconductor industry is currently seeking to reduce such non-uniformities and voids associated with electrochemical deposition processes.

SUMMARY

The present invention is directed toward methods for forming microelectronic workpieces used in electrochemical deposition processes, methods of depositing a conductive layer on a microelectronic workpiece, and articles for electrochemical deposition in semiconductor fabrication. One aspect of the invention is directed toward methods for forming microelectronic workpieces that are well-suited for electrochemical deposition processes. An embodiment of such a method comprises depositing a first conductive material on a workpiece to form an electrically conductive first layer that conforms to the workpiece. This embodiment further includes forming a seed region defined by a second layer of a second conductive material on the first layer and forming a contact region defined by an exposed portion of the first layer that is not covered by the second layer. The contact region can extend around at least a portion of the perimeter of the workpiece.
Another embodiment of a method for forming a microelectronic workpiece in accordance with the invention includes depositing a first conductive material on the workpiece, depositing a second conductive material over the first conductive material, and forming a contact region around a perimeter of the workpiece. The first material is a conductive material that forms an electrically conductive contact layer which conforms to submicron recesses in the workpieces. The second material is a different conductive material that is deposited onto the contact layer to form a seed layer. The second conductive material, for example, can be copper. The contact region is an exposed portion of the contact layer that extends radially inwardly from an edge of the workpiece. The contact region, for example, can be an annular band of the first material around the perimeter of the workpiece that is configured to directly engage the contact points of a workpiece holder used in electrochemical deposition chambers. The contact region can be formed by patterning a resist layer in an annular band around the perimeter of the workpiece and then depositing the second conductive material on the contact layer. Alternatively, the contact region can be formed by depositing the second conductive material over the entire surface area of the workpiece and then etching a portion of the second conductive material from the perimeter of the workpiece.
Another aspect of the invention is a method of depositing a conductive layer on a microelectronic workpiece. In one embodiment, such a method includes depositing a first conductive material on the workpiece to form an electrically conductive contact layer that conforms to submicron recesses in the workpiece and then disposing a second conductive layer on the contact layer to form a seed layer. The method also includes forming a contact region around a perimeter portion of the workpiece that is defined by an exposed portion of the contact layer extending radially inwardly from an edge of the workpiece. The method continues by electroplating additional material onto the seed layer in a plating process that includes engaging an electrical contact directly with the contact region and applying a current directly to the contact region in the presence of an electroplating solution.
Another aspect of the invention is an article for electrochemical deposition of a conductive layer on a workpiece in the fabrication of microelectronic circuits. In one embodiment, such an article includes a workpiece having a plurality of submicron micro-components that define integrated circuits, a first layer on the workpiece, and a second layer over the first layer. The first layer is composed of a first electrically conductive material, and the first layer covers an area of the workpiece having a first diameter. The second layer defines a seed layer composed of a second conducive material different than the first material. The second layer covers an area of the workpiece having a second diameter less than the first diameter such that a portion of the first layer along a perimeter edge of the workpiece is exposed. The exposed portion of the first layer defines a contact region for directly engaging contacts of a workpiece holder.
Another embodiment of an article for electrochemical deposition of a conductive layer on a workpiece includes a workpiece having a plurality of submicron micro-components that define integrated circuits, a barrier layer on the workpiece, and a seed layer over the barrier layer. The barrier layer is composed of a first electrically conductive material. The seed layer is composed of a second conductive material different than the first material, and the seed layer covers only a portion of the barrier layer to leave an exposed portion of the barrier layer along a perimeter edge of the workpiece.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a schematic cross-sectional view of an electrochemical deposition chamber in accordance with the prior art.
FIGS. 2A-2C are schematic cross-sectional views illustrating a method for forming a workpiece in accordance with an embodiment of the invention.
FIG. 3 is a schematic cross-sectional view of a workpiece in accordance with an embodiment of the invention loaded into a workpiece holder for an electrochemical deposition process in accordance with a method of the invention.
FIG. 4 is a schematic cross-sectional view of an electrochemical deposition chamber for electroplating workpieces in accordance with embodiments of the invention.
FIGS. 5A-5D are schematic cross-sectional views illustrating a method for fabricating a workpiece in accordance with another embodiment of the invention.
FIGS. 6A-6C are schematic cross-sectional views of a method for fabricating a workpiece in accordance with yet another embodiment of the invention.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The following disclosure describes methods for forming microelectronic workpieces used in electrochemical deposition processes, methods of depositing conductive layers on microelectronic workpieces, and articles for electrochemical deposition of conductive layers on workpieces in the fabrication of microelectronic circuits. As used herein, the terms “micro-device workpiece” and “microelectronic workpiece” include semiconductor wafers, field emission displays, read/write heads, micro-mechanical devices, and other types of devices that have very small components. Several embodiments of the invention are described below with reference to FIGS. 2-6C, but it will be appreciated that the invention can include other embodiments not shown in these figures. For example, aspects of the invention can include embodiments that do not have all of the features disclosed in FIGS. 2-6C, or other embodiments can include features in addition to those disclosed in these figures. Additionally, the embodiments disclosed in FIGS. 2-6C are directed toward forming damascene conductive lines, but it will be appreciated that they can also be used to form dual-damascene conductive lines, interlayer contacts, and other components in micro-device workpieces. It will be appreciated that several aspects of the invention are particularly suitable for fabricating submicron components on the order of 0.1-0.75 micron or even less than 0.1 micron, but many aspects of the invention may also be useful to fabricate components larger than one micron.
FIG. 2A is a schematic cross-sectional view of a workpiece 100 at one stage of a method in accordance with an embodiment of the invention. The workpiece 100 includes a substrate 102 and a dielectric layer 104 over the substrate 102. The substrate 102 can be a semiconductor substrate that includes a plurality of cells with transistors, shallow trench isolation structures, and other components. The substrate 102 can alternatively be a glass substrate or other material for other types of micro-devices. The dielectric layer 104 is typically a silicon dioxide, a borophosphate silicon glass, a tetraethylorthosilicate, or other suitable dielectric material. In the particular embodiment shown in FIG. 2A, the dielectric layer 104 includes a plurality of micro-recesses 106 that can be contact holes, trenches, or other structures. The micro-recesses 106 typically have a sub-micron width on the order of 0.1-0.5 microns and a depth that can be significantly greater than the width. For example, the aspect ratio of the micro-recesses 106 can range from 3-8. The workpiece 100 also includes a first layer 110 of a first conductive material. The first layer 110 can be a barrier layer composed of tantalum, tungsten, a titanium-tungsten alloy, or other suitable materials that provide good adhesion to the dielectric layer 104 and inhibit migration of bulk fill material to the dielectric layer 104 and/or the substrate 102. The barrier layer is typically deposited to a thickness of 100-5000 Å using chemical vapor deposition, physical vapor deposition, or atomic layer deposition processes.
FIG. 2B is a schematic cross-sectional view illustrating a subsequent stage of forming a microelectronic workpiece. A second layer 120 of a second conductive material is deposited over the first layer 110 using chemical vapor deposition, physical vapor deposition, atomic layer deposition and/or electroless plating processes. The second layer 120 typically defines a seed layer for electroplating additional material onto the workpiece 100 in a manner that fills the micro-recesses 106 with the plated material. For example, to fill the micro-recesses 106 with copper, the second layer 120 is typically a copper seed layer. It will be appreciated that other materials can be used for the second layer 120 to plate other types of metals or polymeric materials onto the workpiece 100. The second layer 120 can be deposited to a thickness of approximately 100-1000 Å, and generally more preferably to a thickness of 200-500 Å. When the second layer 120 is a copper seed layer having a thickness of approximately 100-300 Å, it is generally discontinuous and has several voids (not shown in FIG. 2B). The discontinuity of thin copper seed layers is subject to creating large voids in the plated layer within the micro-recesses. Additionally, copper seed layers are subject to oxidation, which reduces the conductivity of the seed layers. The combination of thin copper seed layers and oxidation causes a drop in the current density from the edge to the center of the workpiece 100 when an electrical contact is engaged directly with the second layer 120 at the perimeter of the workpiece 100.
FIG. 2C is a schematic cross-sectional view of the workpiece 110 at a subsequent stage of the method. This stage of the method involves forming a contact region 130 around a perimeter of the workpiece and a seed region 140 within the contact region 130. The contact region 130 in this embodiment is defined by an exposed portion 132 of the first layer 110 that extends radially inwardly from an edge 134 of the workpiece 100 to the perimeter of the second layer 120. The exposed portion 132 of the first layer 110 is not covered by the second material of the second layer 120. The contact region 130 can be an annular band extending around the perimeter edge of the workpiece 100. The contact region 130 can have a radial width of approximately 1-10 millimeters, and more preferably a radial width of approximately 2-5 millimeters. The seed region 140 is thus defined by the second layer 120. As a result, the first layer 110 covers the surface of the workpiece 100 across an area having a first diameter, and the second layer 120 covers an area of the first layer 110 having a second diameter less than the first diameter such that a portion of the first layer 110 is exposed along the perimeter edge 134 of the workpiece 100. The embodiment of the workpiece 100 shown in FIG. 2C is suitable for subsequent electrochemical deposition processing in which a plurality of electrical contacts touch the exposed portion 132 of the first layer 110 to apply an electrical current directly to the first layer 110 without first applying the electrical current to the second layer 120.
The contact region 130 shown in FIG. 2C can be formed by depositing a layer of resist over the initial deposition of the second layer 120 shown in FIG. 2B (resist not shown). The layer of resist is then patterned and removed around the perimeter of the workpiece, and then the perimeter portion of the second layer 120 is etched away to expose the portion 132 of the first layer 110 shown in FIG. 2C. Suitable photo-patterning and etching processes are well known to those skilled in the art and not described here.
FIG. 3 is a schematic cross-sectional view of the workpiece 100 in a workpiece holder 200 used for electroplating additional material onto the second layer 120. The workpiece holder 200 includes a housing 210, a movable backing plate 220 in one portion of the housing, and an annular rim 230 spaced apart from the backing plate 220. The workpiece holder 200 also includes a plurality of contacts 240 arranged in a circle within the rim 230. Each contact 240 includes a contact point 242 that is configured to engage the workpiece 100. The contact points 242 are generally arranged to circumscribe a circle having a diameter that extends radially inwardly relative to the edge 134 of the workpiece 100.
The workpiece 100 is loaded into the workpiece holder 200, and then the backing plate 220 and/or the annular rim 230 moves to press the contact points 242 directly against the exposed portion 132 of the first layer 110. The lip of the rim 230 also preferably engages the workpiece 100 to form a seal radially inward from the contact points 242. It will be appreciated, however, that certain embodiments can be wet-contact plating processes that do not engage a rim with the workpiece. The contact points 242 accordingly directly engage the surface of the first layer 110 in the contact region to apply an electrical current directly to the first layer. Because the first layer 110 is conductive, the electrical current initially passes through the first layer 110 to provide a uniform current distribution across the workpiece 100. The conductive second layer 120 accordingly conducts the electrical current distributed through the first layer 110 to provide a uniform current distribution across the second layer 120.
FIG. 4 is a schematic cross-sectional view showing an electroplating process for bulk plating material onto the workpiece 100 using the workpiece holder 200 shown in FIG. 3. In operation, the workpiece holder 200 positions the workpiece 100 in a bath of an electroplating solution. As shown in FIG. 4, the workpiece 100 is plated in an electrochemical deposition chamber 400 that includes an upper unit 410 having a head 412 that carries the workpiece holder 200. The ECD chamber 400 also includes a lower unit 420 that has a bowl 422 for containing an electrolyte bath and an electrode 424 positioned in the bowl 422. More specifically, the head 412 can include a rotor 414 that rotatably carries the workpiece holder 200. The head 412 positions the workpiece 100 so that the flow of electrolytic solution engages the face of the workpiece 100. Additionally, an electrical field is established in the electrolytic solution by applying a potential to the electrode 424 in the bowl 422 and the electrodes 240 contacting the contact region of the workpiece 100. The ions in the electrolytic bath accordingly attach to the second layer 120 (FIG. 2C) of the workpiece 100 to fill the micro-recesses 106 (FIG. 2C) with the plated material.
The structure of the workpiece 100 shown in the embodiment of FIG. 2C is expected to provide a more uniform current distribution in the second layer 120 to produce more uniform plating in the micro-recesses 106. The conductive first layer 110 can be a continuous layer without voids even when it is very thin. For example, when the first layer 110 is a thin tantalum layer, it is not subject to including the voids and discontinuities of a thin copper layer. Additionally, thin tantalum layers are not subject to oxidation to the same extent as copper. Therefore, when the contacts 240 apply the current directly to the first layer 110 instead of the second layer 120, the electrical current is generally uniform through the tantalum layer 110. This accordingly produces a uniform current distribution through the second layer 120. As a result, by exposing the contact region on the first layer 110 and engaging the contact point 242 of the contacts 240 directly with the contact region, the embodiments of the workpiece 100 shown in FIG. 2C are expected to produce uniform plating across the face of the workpiece 100.
FIGS. 5A-5D are schematic cross-sectional views of another embodiment of the workpiece 100. Referring to FIG. 5A, the workpiece 100 includes the substrate 102, the dielectric layer with micro-recesses 106, and the first layer 110 as described above. FIG. 5B shows the workpiece 100 at a subsequent stage after a layer of resist has been deposited over the workpiece 100 and patterned to form at least one spacer 115 at the perimeter of the workpiece 100. The spacer 115 can be a continuous annular ring around the perimeter of the workpiece 100 over the first layer 110. Alternatively, a plurality of discrete spacers can be formed over areas where the first layer is to be exposed. FIG. 5C illustrates the workpiece 100 at a subsequent stage of the method after having deposited the second layer 120 over the spacer 115 and the first layer 110. The workpiece 100 is then subject to a process in which the spacer 115 is removed by a suitable wash or etchant to undercut the perimeter portion of the second layer 120. FIG. 5D illustrates the workpiece 100 after removing the spacer 115, which may also remove the undercut portion of the second layer 120 to expose the surface 132 of the first layer 110 and thus define the contact region 130.
FIGS. 6A-6C are schematic views illustrating a workpiece 100 a in accordance with yet another embodiment of the invention. Referring to FIG. 6A, the workpiece 100 a has a substrate 102, a dielectric layer 104 with micro-recesses 106, and a first layer 110 as explained above. The workpiece 100 a also has a layer of resist 115 a which has been patterned to form large openings over the micro-recesses 106. FIG. 6B illustrates the workpiece 100 a after a second layer 120 has been deposited over the first layer 110 and the resist layer 115 a. FIG. 6C illustrates the workpiece 100 a after removing the top portions of the second layer 120 and the resist layer 115 a. To form the structure shown in FIG. 6C from the structure shown in FIG. 6B, the structure shown in FIG. 6B can be planarized to remove the top portions of the second layer 120 over the resist layer 115 a, and then the resist 115 a can be removed from the workpiece using a suitable wash or etchant that does not react with the second layer 120 or the first layer 110. The workpiece 100 a shown in FIG. 6C can accordingly be loaded into a workpiece holder and electroplated as explained above.
From the foregoing, it will be appreciated that specific embodiments of the invention have been described herein for purposes of illustration, but that various modifications may be made without deviating from the spirit and scope of the invention. Accordingly, the invention is not limited except as by the appended claims.

Claims

1-45. (canceled)

46. An article for electrochemical deposition of a conductive layer on a workpiece in the fabrication of microelectronic circuits using a workpiece holder having contacts with contact points arranged to circumscribe a circle, comprising:

a workpiece having a plurality of submicron micro-components that define integrated circuits;

a first layer on the workpiece, the first layer being composed of a first electrically conductive material, and the first layer covering an area of the workpiece having a first diameter greater than a diameter of the circle circumscribed by the contact points;

a second layer over the first layer to define a seed layer, the second layer being composed of a second conductive material different than the first material, and the second layer covering an area of the workpiece having a second diameter less than the first diameter such that a portion of the first layer along a perimeter edge of the workpiece is exposed, and wherein the second diameter is less than the diameter of the circle circumscribed by the contact points.

47. The article of claim 46 wherein:

the first layer comprises a barrier layer that inhibits migration of copper; and

the second layer comprises copper.

48. The article of claim 47 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer comprises a band around the perimeter of the workpiece having a width of approximately 1-10 mm.

49. The article of claim 47 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer comprises a band around the perimeter of the workpiece having a width of approximately 2-5 mm.

50. The article of claim 46 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer has a width extending radially inwardly from a perimeter of the workpiece for a distance of approximately 1-10 mm along at least a portion of the workpiece.

51. The article of claim 50 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer comprises a band extend completely around the workpiece.

52. The article of claim 50 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer comprises an arc extending only around a portion of the workpiece.

53. An article for electrochemical deposition of a conductive layer on a workpiece in the fabrication of microelectronic circuits using a workpiece holder having contacts with contact points arranged to circumscribe a circle, comprising:

a barrier layer on the workpiece, the barrier layer being composed of a first electrically conductive material that covers an area of the workpiece having a first diameter greater than a diameter of the circle circumscribed by the contact points;

a seed layer over the barrier layer, the seed layer being composed of a second conductive material different than the first material, and the seed layer covering an area of the workpiece having a second diameter less than the first diameter such that a portion of the barrier layer is exposed along a perimeter edge of the workpiece, and wherein the second diameter is less than the diameter of the circle circumscribed by the contact points.

54. The article of claim 53 wherein:

the second layer comprises copper.

55. The article of claim 54 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer comprises a band around the perimeter of the workpiece having a width of approximately 1-10 mm.

56. The article of claim 54 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer comprises a band around the perimeter of the workpiece having a width of approximately 2-5 mm.

57. The article of claim 53 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer has a width extending radially inwardly from a perimeter of the workpiece for a distance of approximately 1-10 mm along at least a portion of the workpiece.

58. The article of claim 57 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer comprises a band extend completely around the workpiece.

59. The article of claim 57 wherein the exposed portion of the first layer comprises an arc extending only around a portion of the workpiece.

60. An article for electrochemical deposition of a conductive layer on a workpiece in the fabrication of microelectronic circuits using a workpiece holder having contacts with contact points arranged to circumscribe a circle, comprising:

a barrier layer on the workpiece, the barrier layer being composed of a first electrically conductive material; and

a seed layer composed of a second conductive material different than the first material, wherein the seed layer covers only a portion of the barrier layer to leave an exposed portion of the barrier layer along a perimeter edge of the workpiece, wherein the exposed portion is configured to contact the contact points and the contact points are configured to apply an electrical current directly to the barrier layer.

61. The article of claim 46 wherein the workpiece holder further includes an annular rim configured to engage the workpiece, and wherein the second diameter is approximately equal to a diameter of the rim.

62. The article of claim 46 wherein the exposed area of the first layer is configured to contact the contact points.

63. The article of claim 53 wherein the workpiece holder further includes an annular rim configured to engage the workpiece, and wherein the second diameter is approximately equal to a diameter of the rim.

64. The article of claim 53 wherein the exposed area of the barrier layer is configured to contact the contact points.