DEVICE AND METHOD FOR DELIVERING A MATERIAL INTO THE PARANASAL SINUS CAVITIES
1
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED PROVISIONAL APPLICATIONS
The present application claims the benefit of the earlier filing date of U.S.
Provisional Patent Applications Serial Nos. 60/123,238, filed March 8, 1999, and 60/125,685, filed March 23, 1999, which are incorporated by reference herein in their entireties. FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates to a device and method for treating sinus disease. More particularly, the present invention relates to a device and method for delivering a material into the middle meatus and paranasal sinus cavities. BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Sinus disease is a common human affliction associated with substantial economic costs. In the United States alone, approximately 1 million cases of viral sinusitis, 20 million cases of bacterial sinusitis, and 200,000 cases of chronic sinusitis are reported each year. In the course of evaluating and treating these types of sinus disease, as well as cases of
allergic sinusitis, the common cold, and other sinus diseases, it is often desirable to deliver pharmaceutical agents, as well as other therapeutic and diagnostic materials, into the middle
meatus or, better still, the paranasal sinus cavities. The effective treatment of any sinus disease ultimately depends upon
delivering adequate quantities of therapeutic material into the paranasal sinus cavities. Unfortunately, conventional techniques for treating sinus disease have been unable to reliably
effect delivery of sufficient materials into the paranasal sinus cavities. Indeed, conventional techniques have been largely incapable of delivering effective quantities of therapeutic
materials even as far as the middle meatus. The only techniques which have been able to reliably deliver sufficient quantities of materials into the paranasal sinus cavities are invasive, ^ involving punctures or the opening of passages through flesh and bone, and therefore viewed as alternatives of last resort.
Materials delivered into the nasal passages using conventional devices such as those involving nose drops, nasal sprays, or aerosols are substantially blocked from reaching
the middle meatus, and therefore the paranasal sinuses, by natural obstructions present in the nasal passages. Human nasal passages are variegated and sinuous due to the presence of three turbinates and other structures projecting from the lateral wall. The paranasal sinuses are air-filled cavities that drain in the nasal passages by narrow portals or ostea. As the
sinuses are surrounded by bone, the geometry of the nasal passages makes it difficult to directly access the sinus openings to deliver pharmaceuticals or other materials into the paranasal sinuses. A significant failing of such conventional devices is that they deliver
materials under the inferior turbinate, thereby rendering such materials incapable of
navigating the complex geometry of the nasal airways to reach the middle meatus or the
paranasal sinus cavities. Accordingly, conventional devices are largely incapable of delivering materials into the paranasal sinus cavities. Accordingly, it is desirable to identify a
device and method capable of safely, non-invasively, effectively and reliably depositing material, including medication, into the middle meatus and paranasal sinus cavities.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The device and method of the present invention addresses the several
shortcomings and disadvantages of conventional techniques for treating sinus disease. The
device of the present invention generally includes an elongated body portion having a distal end and a proximal end, and a passage therethrough extending from the proximal end to the
distal end of the body portion. The distal end of the body portion may have a separate or
integral tip portion. The tip portion may have a spray orifice, and is anatomically curved for inserting the tip portion through the nasal passages and positioning it in the middle meatus (ostiomeatal complex). The curved portion of the tip portion includes a first curve or bend, and may include a second curve or bend that is disposed orthogonally to the first curve. The first and second curves preferably are selected to ensure that the tip portion of the device will
be positioned in line-of-sight to the top of the inferior turbinate bone in the subject or
patient's nasal cavity upon insertion of the device. Such positioning will permit a material to be deposited on top of the turbinate bone in the middle meatus of the subject's nasal cavity,
greatly increasing the ability of the material to reach the paranasal sinus cavities. Preferably,
the distal end of the device is coated with a low-friction, biocompatible lubricant or other material, such as Teflon® or K-Y Jelly®, to aid the comfortable insertion of the device.
The tip portion may be configured to be detachable from the body portion of
the device. If the tip portion is detachable, it can also be disposable, reducing the cost of
using the device. Of course, the entire device may be configured so as to be disposable after
one or more uses.
The proximal end of the body portion is configured to receive a material to be directed through the passage in the body portion and out the tip portion of the device. The
device also may include a reservoir attached to the proximal end of the body portion, which
may be used to hold a quantity of material for delivery. A pressure device also may be operatively attached to the device of the present invention, the pressure device being configured to apply pressure sufficient to deliver a material, such as a liquid medication, through the body portion and out the tip portion (distal portion) of the device and into a
subject's middle meatus. The pressure device may be further configured (or a separate pressure device may be employed) to apply pressure sufficient to increase the pressure in the subject's nasal passages and thereby assist the movement of the material into one or more of the subject's paranasal cavities from the middle meatus. The pressure device may be formed
as a component separate from the device of the present invention, and may be configured to also function as the reservoir. The reservoir and pressure device, whether alone or in
combination, may include, for example, a syringe, a flexible bulb, or a clinical pressure system of the type frequently found in physician's offices. Where a clinical pressure system is to be utilized, the device of the present invention may include an adaptor to attach to such a
system.
The device also may include a guide attached to the body portion of the device, the guide being designed to assist in properly inserting the distal end of the body
portion of the device into a subject's nasal cavity. The guide may include one or more of an
insertion limiting portion, an abutment portion, and a vestibule locating portion.
Generally, the method of the present invention includes two steps. The first step of the method of the present invention includes delivering a material into the subject's - '. middle meatus. The second step of the method includes applying pressure in the subject's
nasal passages sufficient to deliver the material into one or more of the subject's paranasal
sinus cavities. The first step of the method of the present invention may further include providing a device, such as the device of the present invention, for delivering the material
into the middle meatus, and ultimately into one or more of the subject's paranasal sinus cavities. The second step of the method of the present invention may be performed, for
example, by having the subject perform a nose blow or Valsalva's maneuver, or by providing a pressure device capable of increasing the pressure in the subject's nasal passages, such that a pressure is applied which is sufficient to deliver the material into one or more of the
subject's paranasal sinus cavities.
The foregoing and other features, objects and advantages of the present
invention will be apparent from the following detailed description, taken in connection with the accompanying figures, the scope of the invention being set forth in the appended claims.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated into and form a part of
the instant specification, illustrate several aspects and embodiments of the present invention and, together with the description herein, serve to explain the principles of the invention. The
drawings are provided only for the purpose of illustrating preferred embodiments of the
invention and are not to be construed as limiting the invention. In the drawings:
FIG. 1 is an elevational side view of one embodiment of the device of the present invention.
FIG. 2A is a cross-sectional side view of one embodiment of a tip portion of the device of the present invention.
FIG. 2B is an elevational top view of the tip portion of the embodiment of the device of FIG. 2A.
FIG. 3 is a partial orthogonal representation of the human nasal passages, illustrating the preferred insertion of the embodiment of the device of FIG. 1.
FIG. 4 is a partial cross-sectional representation of the human nasal passages, illustrating the insertion of another embodiment of the device of the present invention.
FIG. 5 is a graph illustrating the intranasal pressure time history for a human
subject during a nose blow.
FIG. 6 is a graph illustrating the effect of the application of an external
pressure transient on aqueous fluid flow over time into a typical human maxillary sinus. FIG. 7 is a graph illustrating the effect of an external pressure transient on total
aqueous fluid flow in a typical human maxillary sinus.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
The present invention includes a method and device for delivering a material
into the middle meatus, and ultimately into the paranasal sinus cavities (maxillary, ethmoid,
sphenoid and frontal). The device and method of the present invention can be designed to
deliver a number of materials including liquids, gases, powders, and slurries for a number of
different purposes, such as diagnostic and therapeutic purposes, among others.
One embodiment of the device of the present invention is illustrated in FIG. 1.
As shown in that figure, the device 10 generally includes an elongated body portion 12 having a proximal end 13 and a distal end 15. Body portion 12 defines a passage therein extending from proximal end 13 to distal end 15. Body portion 12 may be constructed in various lengths as appropriate to the needs and circumstances of use. For example, body portion 12 is
anatomically shaped and constructed of a length such that device 10 may be held at proximal
end 13 for insertion into a human nose, and extension into the middle meatus at distal end 15. Such a body portion 12 may be further refined to custom-fit a particular human subject. Body portion 12 may be constructed of any suitable material or combination of materials, including
one or more thermoplastics or other materials which are biocompatible, sufficiently soft to be comfortable to a human or other subject, and sufficiently rigid to retain their shape, yet not so rigid as to be uncomfortably unyielding when being positioned in a subject's nasal passages. It may have a cross-section that is cylindrical, or any other shape that is advantageous for
design or application purposes. The cross-section of device 10 preferably is as small as
possible.
Proximal end 13 is configured to receive a material to be directed into the passage in body portion 12. For example, proximal end 13 may include a reservoir 14, as in
FIG. 1 , or otherwise be connected to a reservoir 14, containing a material to be delivered to
the middle meatus of a subject's nasal passages. Reservoir 14 may be any type of device
capable of holding a material for introduction into the passage through body portion 12. For example, reservoir 14 may be constructed as a flexible bulb such as that used in connection
with conventional blood pressure measurement devices, as illustrated in FIG. 1, or may
comprise a conventional syringe or any other device capable of containing the material to be
delivered. The volume of reservoir 14 must be large enough to contain a volume of a chosen
material sufficient for that material to effect the desired purpose once it reaches the subject's paranasal sinuses. For example, where it is desired to therapeutically treat a subject's sinus disease, the reservoir should be capable of holding a volume of the chosen material which is
sufficient for the material to be therapeutically effective.
As shown generally in FIGS. 1 and 2 A, distal end 15 of body portion 12 incorporates a first curve 17 which, for use in connection with human subjects, is in the range
of approximately 20 to 45 degrees. The range of the curve may be different for animal subjects than for humans, and may be custom fit for optimal effect for a given subject. First
curve 17 is designed to facilitate the insertion of device 10 through a subject's nasal vestibule
and into the anterior portion of the middle meatus. Once device 10 is inserted, as illustrated in FIG. 3, distal end 15 of device 10 will be positioned in line-of sight of the space between the inferior turbinate and the middle turbinate bone, and therefore in line of sight with the
sinus ostia, allowing delivery of the material from the middle meatus and into one or more of
the paranasal sinus cavities. Due to first curve 17, distal end 15 of device 10 is able, when so positioned, to maintain a spray direction ensuring an optimum spray pattern for the delivery of material into the anterior portion of the middle meatus. The incorporation of first curve 17
also serves to reduce or eliminate the drowning sensation that may otherwise be experienced
by a subject.
As shown in FIGS. 1-4, distal end 15 of body portion 12 may have an integral
or detachable tip portion 16. Preferably, tip portion 16 contains first curve 17, provides the
desirably elliptical shape for distal end 15 of body portion 12 (as is discussed in greater detail
below), and where a powder or liquid spray is desired, is equipped with a spray orifice similar to those used in conventional spray devices in order to provide a fine or coarse powder or
liquid spray. Tip portion 16 may be constructed from any suitable material, such as one or more thermoplastics. In the embodiment of FIGS. 2 A and 2B, for example, tip portion 16 is a heat-shrunk thermoplastic sheath 19 over a looped stainless steel spring wire 20. Of course,
tip portion 16 may be fabricated without wire 20 to define its shape, for example, by blow
molding, extrusion or injection molding. As another alternative, for example, tip portion 16
may be formed by embedding a small diameter tube (e.g., Teflon® spaghetti tube) in an elastomeric material, the latter of which may be cast or cured to form the desired shape. Tip portion 16, or distal end 15 itself if a tip portion is not employed, preferably is coated with a
biocompatible material or lubricant, such as Teflon® or K-Y Jelly®, to aid the insertion of device 10 through the subject's nasal vestibule and into the anterior portion of the subject's
middle meatus. Tip portion 16 preferably has an elliptical shape. In the embodiment of
FIGS. 2A and 2B, this shape is formed by the looped stainless steel wire previously
discussed, and tip portion 16 has a cross-section measuring approximately 2 millimeters by 4
millimeters. In this embodiment, first curve 17 lies in the plane of the 2 millimeter
dimension. The overall length of device 10 in the embodiment of FIG. 1 is between 8 and 12 centimeters and the length from the distal end 18 of tip portion 16 to the start of first curve 17
is 5 centimeters.
Distal end 15 of body portion 12 preferably includes a second curve 19 in an
orthogonal relationship to first curve 17. Where a tip portion 16 is employed, as illustrated in
FIG. 2B, second curve 19 is imparted to tip portion 16 over the same length of body portion 12 where first curve 17 occurs. Second curve 19 is generally less than or equal to approximately 30 degrees, and preferably is approximately 20 degrees. The magnitude of
second curve 19 may be optimized, like first curve 17, in accordance with the anatomy of a particular subject. Although not essential to the efficacy of device 10, second curve 19 may operate in conjunction with orthogonal curve 17 to further facilitate the insertion of device 10 through the nasal vestibule and into the anterior portion of the middle meatus.
Device 10 may include, or be adapted for use with, a pressure device
operatively attached to device 10 to apply pressure sufficient to deliver a material from proximal end 13, through the passage in body portion 12, out tip portion 16 and into a subject's middle meatus. The same pressure device, or an additional pressure or flow device,
may be designed to selectively increase the pressure or flow in a subject's nasal passages
sufficiently to facilitate the delivery of material to the middle meatus, or sufficiently to
facilitate the delivery of such material to one or more of the paranasal sinus cavities. Examples of such a device include a common syringe or flexible bulb, both of which may
serve a dual purpose as the pressure device and reservoir 14. For example, the flexible bulb serving as reservoir 14 in FIG. 1 could be manually compressed to create a pressure, forcing a
sufficient volume of liquid medicine or other material in reservoir 14 through the passage in
body portion 12 and into a subject's middle meatus or paranasal sinuses. However, the pressure device and reservoir 14 need not be so combined, as the pressure device may
comprise, for example, a separate hand-held pressure applicator, a positive pressure pump or
a clinical pressure system of the type commonly found in physician's offices.
The pressure device must be capable of delivering a level of pressure which is effective to drive a sufficient volume of medicines or other selected materials into the middle meatus, or better still, the paranasal sinuses. As is discussed in greater detail below, a pressure of approximately 66 mm-Hg has been found to be sufficient to drive material from
the middle meatus into the paranasal sinuses, but lower pressures (perhaps as low as 60 mm-
Hg or lower) are also expected to be sufficient. A pressure regulator preferably is used in
combination with or as part of the pressure device to ensure that the pressure applied to a subject's nasal passages will not reach a level at which tissue damage or the introduction of
air to the bloodstream may result. It is believed that pressures up to approximately 80 mm-
Hg are generally safe for use in human nasal passages, although pressures as high as 176 mm-
Hg have been safely demonstrated during sneezing with nostrils occluded.
Referring now to FIG. 4, device 10 may include a guide 22 configured to assist a user in comfortably and effectively positioning distal end 15 of body portion 12 into a
subject's nasal passages. In the embodiment of FIG. 4, for example, guide 22 is designed to include an insertion limiting portion 24 that, by having a cross section larger than the vestibule of a subject's nose, prevents device 10 from extending into a subject's nasal
passages more than a preselected distance. Guide 22 also may be constructed to include a
vestibule locating portion 28 which may serve the same function as an insertion limiting
portion, or may alternatively or additionally serve to seat device 10 in the vestibule of a subject's nose. Another potential feature of guide 22 is an abutment portion 26 configured to
assist the proper and consistent application of device 10 by ensuring a proper angle and
orientation relative to a subject's body. For example, the abutment portion 26 of guide 22
shown in FIG. 4 is configured to comfortably abut a human subject's upper lip. As an
alternative embodiment, guide 22 may be separate from device 10 and placed in the vestibule of a subj ect' s nose prior to use of the device.
Guide 22 may be attached to, or integrally formed with, device 10. Alternatively, guide 22 may be configured so that, once guide 22 is in place in the vestibule
of a subject's nose, body portion 12 of device 10 may be inserted through a passage in guide
22 and into the subject's nasal passages. In such an embodiment, guide 22 preferably includes a manually operable cam (not shown) or other device for selectively fixing guide 22
to body portion 12, so that the position of guide 22 relative to distal end 15 of body portion 12 may be adjusted as needed.
The present invention also includes a non-invasive method for delivering a material into one or more of a subject's paranasal sinus cavities. In generally, the method of the present invention involves two principle steps. The first step is to deliver a quantity of
material into the subject's middle meatus. The second step is to apply a pressure to the
subject's nasal passages sufficient to deliver the material into one or more of the subject's
paranasal sinus cavities.
The first step of the method of the present invention may be carried out with the subject's head positioned parallel to the floor or in another inclined or reclined position,
or with the subject in the supine position, to increase the residence time of the material
delivered in the middle meatus. The second step also may be performed while the subject's head is in same position, or in another position provided that the second step of the method is
performed before the material has drained from the middle meatus. The material preferably is
delivered to the middle meatus in the first step using a device, such as those illustrated in the
embodiments of FIGS. 1-4, configured to consistently deposit a selected amount of material in the middle meatus with maximum efficacy and comfort.
Once the material has been delivered to the subject's middle meatus, the second step of the present invention may be performed by applying a pressure in the subject's
nasal cavity sufficient to drive a sufficient volume of the material from the middle meatus
into one or more of the paranasal sinus cavities. This application of pressure may be accomplished in any suitable manner. For example, the subject may be asked to blow the
subject's nose, or to perform Valsalva's maneuver (i.e., with nose and mouth closed). Although such methods of applying pressure have the potential disadvantage that the magnitude of the pressure actually applied is unknown, the inventors hereof have found that such methods typically provide pressures sufficient to drive substantial volumes of the material delivered to the middle meatus into one or more of the paranasal sinuses. Another
way to apply the requisite pressure is by external means, such as using a pump or other device
as described previously in connection with device 10 of the embodiments of FIGS. 1-4. This
second step of the method of the present invention uses the air that is naturally present in the subject's sinus cavities as a "surge tank" that contracts under the application of fluid pressure
in the subject's nasal passages. This contraction allows the flow of material into the subject's
paranasal sinus cavities through natural passages present in the subject's nasal passageway.
It will now be appreciated that the present invention solves many disadvantages of conventional techniques for treating sinus disease, including but not limited
to acute viral sinusitis (as with the common cold), acute bacterial sinusitis, chronic sinusitis
which has not been subject to surgery, and allergic sinusitis. For example, the device and method of the present invention represent a non-invasive technique by which to ensure that
material, such as a topical medication, will reach the middle meatus. In addition, the present
invention greatly increases the user's ability to ensure that an effective dosage of medication or other material will be deposited in the middle meatus, and not merely be deposited on one or more of the various nasal surfaces leading to the middle meatus and thereby wasted. The
device of the present invention also ensures that the selected material will be able to be
deposited, with a maximum of comfort and safety, in the anterior portion of the middle meatus so that it may more easily be directed into one or more of the paranasal sinuses, and provides for the application of a pressure sufficient to ensure that the material reaches one or
more of the paranasal sinuses. In addition, the device of the present invention may be made
to be adjustable and capable of being optimized to the anatomy of a particular subject.
Example 1 Materials and Methods Healthy adult volunteers with no history of nasal symptoms for one month
prior to the time of the volunteers' selection were recruited. Intranasal pressures were measured during nose blowing, sneezing, and coughing with a Millar SP-524 catheter pressure transducer (catheter diameter 2.5 French, transducer diameter 3.0 French) positioned above the inferior turbinate and a DSP Traq-Q data acquisition system. Data was sampled at
200 Hz and anti-aliasing filtering was performed at 66 Hz. The effective bandwidth of sensor
signals was approximately 0.02-66 Hz.
Nose blowing (both nostrils open or one occluded) and coughing were
initiated voluntarily by the subjects. Sneezing (both nostrils and mouth open or both nostrils
and mouth occluded) was induced by touching the inferior turbinate with a cotton swab t saturated with histamine (concentration 25 mg/mL).
Limited coronal CT scans of the paranasal sinuses were obtained with subjects
in the supine position, using a standard clinical imager. Non-ionic iodinated contrast media
(Iohexol 350, Nycomed, Princeton, NJ) was instilled prior to nose blowing, coughing, or sneezing. In 3 volunteers, 3 mL of contrast were instilled into the nasopharynx followed by
nose blowing while the volunteer remained supine. This procedure was repeated 3 times, and then a limited, direct coronal CT image was obtained with the subject in the prone position. In the fourth volunteer, who was unable to cooperate with the application of contrast into the nasopharynx because of his gag reflex, 5 mL of contrast were instilled onto the floor of each
nasal cavity with the subject supine. The volunteer then blew his nose, and a CT scan was
obtained. In one volunteer, 3 mL of contrast were placed in the nasopharynx by way of mouth followed by repeated forceful voluntary coughing. This procedure was repeated with 4
mL of contrast, and a CT was obtained with the subject prone. In a second volunteer, 4 mL of contrast was put into the nasopharynx once. The volunteer coughed forcefully and repeatedly
twice. A second application of contrast was not made because of a large amount of residual contrast in the nasopharynx after the first coughing episode. In a third volunteer who had excessive gagging with stimulation of the nasopharynx, 6 mL of contrast were applied onto
the floor of the nose on each side followed by 4 episodes of voluntary coughing with the
volunteer supine. The general procedure for instilling contrast into the nasopharynx for
sneezing was the same as above, except that contrast was only instilled once because repeated
episodes of sneezing could not be elicited. One subject who received 2 mL of contrast while
supine sneezed 2 times following histamine challenge. A second volunteer who received 4 mL of contrast sneezed once, and a third who received 6 mL of contrast sneezed 4 times. Simulated sneezes were studied in the remaining 2 volunteers.
Results
A summary of the results of the foregoing testing is provided in the following table.
Table 1
As shown in Table 1 , the mean (± SD) maximum transient intranasal pressure measured in the 4 subjects during multiple nose blows was 66 (± 14) mm-Hg. Pressure transients from nose blowing with both nostrils open (N = 21) did not differ from those with
one nostril occluded (N = 14). Therefore, all nose blowing measurements were combined on
the analysis (N = 35). A graph of the increase in intranasal pressure measured with a transducer in the nasal passages of one of the human volunteers performing a voluntary nose blow is shown in FIG 5. The graph of FIG. 5 illustrates an increase in intranasal pressure of
over 60 mm-Hg for one of the volunteers during a nose blow. The mean (± SD) peak
intranasal pressure from 18 voluntary coughing bouts was 6.6 (± 2.6) mm-Hg, and that from 1
minute of tidal breathing by each of 4 subjects was 0.9 (± 0.4) mm-Hg. The mean pressure
associated with nose blowing was significantly different (p < 0.01, Student's t-test). When a i subject's mouth and nose were closed during a histamine-induced sneeze, large increases in transient intranasal pressure occurred. Two subjects did this by trapping a sneeze with a
tissue, resulting in peak pressures of 176 and 128 mm-Hg for one subject and 88 mm-Hg for the other.
As can be seen in Table 1, the mean (± SD) durations of the intranasal pressure transients were 1.9 (± 0.6), 2.2 (± 0.6), and 0.4 (± 0.2) seconds with nose blows, coughing
bouts, and sneezes, respectively. Even when sneezing occurred with the subject's mouth
closed and nose occluded, the mean duration of the pressure transient was only 0.56 seconds,
which was considerably shorter than that observed with a typical nose blow. With tidal breathing, intranasal pressure transients were characterized by sinusoidal waves of long duration and very small amplitude.
Modeling of Nasal Fluid Flow in the Maxillary Sinus A simple fluid model was used to demonstrate nasal fluid flow. This model incorporated a middle meatus and an infundibulum filled with viscous fluid and a spherical
maxillary sinus cavity partially filled with air at a standard atmospheric pressure of 760 mm-
Hg. The maxillary sinus cavity had a volume of 14.25 mL and the cylindrical infundibulum
had a diameter of 3 mm and a length of 7 mm. These parameters are within normal ranges
for the maxillary sinus (Goldman, Principles and Practice of Rhinology (1987)). A
logarithmic model of visco-elastic fluid was used in the simple model based on previous
measurements of nasal mucus showing a viscosity of over 500 Pa-s at shear rates of 0.01 1/s
and of less than 0.02 Pa-s at shear rates of 100 1/s. A half sine pressure transient with an
amplitude equal to the average maximum pressure measured in the experiments was used in i the model for both the nose blowing and sneezing. The sine half period used for each activity was equal to the average duration of each event as found experimentally.
The graph of FIG. 6 was developed by modeling the measured parameters as
set forth in Table 1. As illustrated in FIG. 6, the model indicates that 1.0 mL of viscous nasal
fluid may be pushed into the maxillary sinus from the mean pressure transient associated with
a nose blow (66.2 mm-Hg). This is a substantial volume, and 20 times the volume of fluid contained in the lumen of the infundibulum (0.05 mL). On the other hand, a typical sneeze
(with both nostrils open) generated an intranasal pressure (4.6 mm-Hg) that could only move an amount of viscous fluid into the maxillary sinus which is less than the volume contained in the infundibulum. The difference in maximum pressure transients and durations between nose blows and sneezes accounts for a large part, but not all, of the amount of the fluid flow
into the sinus. Another significant contribution to fluid movement is the effect of shear rate
on nasal fluid viscosity. In the model, nose blowing was associated with a maximum shear
rate in the infundibulum of over 1500 1/s. This shear rate would result in a low fluid viscosity in the range of 0.001 Pa-s. In contrast, with sneezing the maximum shear rate only
approximated 180 1/s, resulted in a viscosity of over 0.01 Pa-s. In addition, the low
maximum shear rate with sneezing occurs over a much shorter time period than does the
much higher shear rate associated with nose blowing. During a normal sneeze, the nasal fluid
remains considerably more viscous and resistant to flow into the sinus than it does with the
large shear rate that accompanies a nose blow.
CT Examinations with Intranasal Contrast Medium
Following nose blowing, contrast was seen in the ostiomeatal complex and in
the ethmoid and sphenoid sinuses of all four volunteers, and contrast was present in the infundibulum and maxillary and frontal sinuses of 2 of 4 subjects. In addition, contrast
outlined occasional bubbles in the maxillary and sphenoid sinuses of one of the subjects after nose blowing. Following histamine induced sneezes, contrast did not appear in the
infundibulum or sinus cavities of any of the volunteers. Similarly, contrast was not detected
in these areas following simulated sneezing in 2 volunteers. Following coughing, the CT
scan of one of 3 subjects showed a small amount of contrast in the infundibulum bilaterally. Otherwise, cough was not associated with contrast being in the paranasal sinuses.
The fluid model confirms that pressure transients of magnitudes seen
physiologically in nose blows and Valsalva's maneuver are sufficient to drive a substantial flow of material into one or more of the sinus cavities from the nasal passages, and that coughing and sneezing (nostrils/mouth open) do not generate pressures sufficient to cause such flows. As can be seen in FIG. 7, the model predicts that varying the peak amplitude of
the pressure transient changes the amount of material that flows from the nasal passages into
the sinus.
It is believed that the many advantages of the present invention will now be
apparent to those skilled in the art. It will also be apparent that a number of variations and
modifications may be made thereto without departing from the spirit and scope of the
foregoing written description. Accordingly, the foregoing description is to be construed as
illustrative only, rather than limiting. The present invention is limited only by the scope of the following claims.